Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildWhat the Rule Offers
When a county can't meet CMS adequacy standards, the regulation offers an exception under 42 CFR 422.116(f), and it isn't a formality: MedPAC reports CMS denied 259 of 448 requests in 2021, or 58%. Inability to contract is not a valid reason. Here are the two doors in the rule, and what looks like an exception but isn't.
Under 42 CFR 422.116(f)(1)(i), both halves have to be true at once. Certain providers or facilities are not available in that county and specialty, as shown in the Provider Supply file. And the plan has contracted with other providers, possibly beyond the time and distance standard, who are currently available and accessible to most enrollees, consistent with the local pattern of care.
When It Applies
What to Have Ready
What Undercuts It
Filing Notes
Use CMS's current exception request template, in HPMS under Monitoring, Network Management, Documentation, Templates. Forms and supporting documents go up as separate PDFs inside a single zip file. Non-contracted providers that don't fit on the form go on the overflow template. Plans must resubmit all previously approved exceptions whenever CMS requests an HSD upload.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Criterion | Supply-Based Exception | Facility-Based I-SNP | Partial County or Dropping |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where it comes from | 42 CFR 422.116(f)(1)(i) | 42 CFR 422.116(f)(1)(ii) | Partial county: 42 CFR 422.2. Dropping: your own decision |
| What it turns on | Supply, and the local pattern of care | How enrollees receive care, or additional telehealth benefits | Partial county: necessary, nondiscriminatory, and in beneficiaries' best interests |
| Is inability to contract enough? | No | Only where the reason is how enrollees receive care | No, for a partial county |
| How it goes in | CMS's current exception template in HPMS | CMS's current exception template in HPMS | Partial County Justification template, for a partial county |
| The catch | Resubmit whenever CMS requests an HSD upload | Only facility-based I-SNPs under that contract | You don't serve the county, or all of it |
Filing Process
Run this for each failing county and specialty pair. It's our checklist, so confirm the details against CMS's current guidance and template instructions.
Pull the Automated Criteria Check result and the ZIP Code Report for Failed Counties. Note whether you failed the minimum count, the time and distance percentage, or both, and which threshold applies: 85% of beneficiaries in Micro, Rural, and CEAC counties, 90% in Large Metro and Metro.
Pull the Provider Supply file for the specialty in the failing county and every adjacent county, across state lines where relevant. Add the providers the file misses, using state licensing boards, NPPES, hospital medical staff lists, and your own claims.
Contracted, in recruitment, or not available for a listed reason, with no blanks. Attach dated proof for each provider marked not available. If a row's real reason is price or a stalled negotiation, take it out and send it back to contracting.
Use claims showing where members in the county get this specialty today, set against the closer non-contracted providers and the farther contracted ones. Show the contracted alternatives are real: addresses, distances, new-patient status, and hours.
Cover how supply differs from CMS's files, why access is consistent with or better than the Original Medicare pattern of care, and why approval is in the best interests of beneficiaries.
Use CMS's current template from HPMS, with separate PDFs and the overflow template if needed, in one zip file, plus every previously approved exception on the contract. Have someone outside contracting read it first and ask one question: is this a supply problem or a negotiation story?
Blueprint Platform
Blueprint scores your network by county and specialty against CMS's 2026 standards, on straight-line distance: a straight-line pass shows as unconfirmed, and drive time isn't measured. For a failing county, it prints a draft exception request with available providers, CMS-accepted reasons, and your pattern of care. It doesn't decide whether you qualify or file anything. Your team reviews and files.
FAQ