Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildA CMS deficiency notice sets a response deadline. Your response is a chance to upload corrected tables and to file exceptions where they apply. This guide covers the three ways to deal with a failing county, what to have ready, and where Blueprint helps.
Response Timeline
The date is in CMS's notice. For an applicant, the last round is the Notice of Intent to Deny, with 10 days to respond. Contracting and credentialing each take time, so front-load the work. This order of work is our advice, not a CMS process.
Response Pathways
Close the gap if you can. File an exception only where supply really isn't there. If neither holds, dropping the county is an honest option.
Add contracted providers in range and upload corrected HSD tables. A county that fails the time and distance test needs a contracted provider in range or an approved exception.
What It Takes
Where the providers really aren't there, you can file under 42 CFR 422.116(f). You have to prove the providers are not available, and that your contracted providers are available and accessible to most enrollees, consistent with the local pattern of care. Inability to contract is not a valid reason.
What It Takes
If the honest obstacle is price, or the evidence for an exception isn't there, dropping the county is a legitimate choice. An applicant then doesn't enroll there for the year. An operating contract has member and filing obligations of its own, so work through them with your CMS Account Manager and counsel.
What It Takes
Your Response
Follow what the notice itself asks for, and check CMS's current guidance and template instructions. This is what we'd have in hand, built early rather than at the last minute.
What to Avoid
Responses tend to fail on process and on the wrong argument, not on intent. These are the errors that turn a solvable problem into a denied county or a compliance action.
Treating effort as the defense
A log of unanswered calls won't excuse a gap. CMS's guidance says inability to contract is not a valid exception reason, because the non-interference clause keeps CMS out of plan and provider negotiations
Counting providers who aren't ready
CMS's guidance says plans list providers with a fully executed contract. Also check credentialing: a provider signed in response to the notice may be on the table long before members can see them
Filing an exception that is really a rate dispute
If the honest reason a provider isn't in network is the rate, you don't have an exception. Your options are to pay, recruit someone else, or drop the county
Leaving providers off the request
MedPAC says the most common reason CMS denied an exception in 2021 was finding providers within the criteria that the plan "failed to include" on the request or HSD tables
Missing the date
Treat the response date as hard. For an applicant, the response to a Notice of Intent to Deny is the final upload opportunity, due within 10 days under 42 CFR 422.502(c)(2)(ii)
Treating the notice as a one-time event
Once it's resolved, ask why you missed the gap and what would have caught it. If the same counties come up again in the next review, you have a monitoring problem, not a filing problem
Blueprint Platform
Blueprint doesn't track CMS notices or upload anything to HPMS, and your team still writes and files the response. If your team has been working in Blueprint, the scoring and the outreach history are already on each provider when a notice arrives.
Blueprint doesn't read the notice for you. Score your network, and the failing counties and specialties sit next to a ranked list of providers who could close them. Distance is straight-line, so a pass shows as unconfirmed, and drive time isn't measured.
Outreach and decline reasons are recorded on the provider, showing who did what and when, ready for your team to pull into a response.
Re-score after contracts are signed to see which gaps remain, with credentialing status on each provider. Blueprint tracks that status. It doesn't perform credentialing.
Where supply is the problem, Blueprint prints a draft with the available providers, the reasons on record, and the pattern of care. Your team reviews and files it.
FAQ