Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildRural counties are where network builds fail. Here are the strategies health plans use to meet adequacy when the provider supply is thin.
In Large Metro and Metro counties, the primary adequacy challenge is usually contracting: there are enough providers, but getting them to agree to your terms takes time. In rural counties, the challenge is structural: the providers simply don't exist in sufficient numbers to satisfy CMS time-and-distance thresholds, regardless of how good your contracting team is. Rural adequacy failures are not execution failures; they are supply constraint problems that require different solutions.
The good news is that CMS, state Medicaid agencies, and most state insurance departments have all developed mechanisms to address rural adequacy challenges, because the alternative, denying plans the ability to serve rural members, is worse for everyone. Understanding these mechanisms and deploying them strategically is the core competency of rural network management.
Telehealth-only providers don't count as physical locations or toward the minimum provider count. What CMS offers instead is a credit: for the 15 specialty types listed in 42 CFR 422.116(d)(5), including psychiatry, clinical psychology, clinical social work and primary care, a plan with contracted telehealth providers in that specialty gets a 10 percentage point credit toward the required share of beneficiaries in a county.
For rural counties with behavioral health gaps, that credit can close a gap that is within 10 points of the threshold. It lowers the bar. It does not by itself cure a larger deficiency.
State Medicaid rules on telehealth differ from the MA rules. If you're operating a Medicaid managed care plan or D-SNP in a rural state, check your state contract for its own telehealth provisions.
There is no general adequacy waiver in Medicare Advantage. The route is an exception request under 42 CFR 422.116(f), filed in HPMS for one county and one specialty. You must show that the providers you would need are not available, and that the providers you did contract with are currently available and accessible to most enrollees, consistent with the local pattern of care. CMS's guidance says inability to contract is not a valid reason. A sound request includes:
State Medicaid exception processes vary. Some states may have formal processes with specified forms and timelines; others handle rural adequacy gaps through informal dialogue with the plan during the annual contract review. Know your state's process before your first submission: the process itself takes time to navigate.
Federally Qualified Health Centers are often the highest-volume primary care providers in rural counties, and they are typically willing to contract with managed care plans because their funding model depends on serving insured patients. In many rural counties, the FQHC is the only provider delivering comprehensive primary care, contracting with it solves your primary care adequacy gap and gives you an anchor provider whose patient relationships can anchor your member base.
FQHC payment works differently from a physician practice, so understand the clinic's Medicare and Medicaid rates before you open the rate discussion. Negotiate with the FQHC's CFO, not just the provider relations contact: the financial terms are the core of the FQHC's decision, and the CFO has to approve.
Beyond primary care, many FQHCs in rural areas have expanded to offer behavioral health, dental, and pharmacy services. A single FQHC contract can meaningfully address adequacy across multiple specialty categories in a rural county.
In rural markets, many specialists serve multiple counties on a rotating basis: a cardiologist from the regional medical center may hold clinic in a rural county once a month, for example. These traveling specialists may help in that county if they are contracted. Confirm in CMS's current guidance how a part-time location is listed and counted before you rely on it. CMS's December 2024 guidance says providers should be listed at the addresses where they see patients in an office-based setting.
The key is identifying which specialists are already coming to the county: hospital medical staff directories, local hospital outreach records, and conversations with the FQHC's patient services team are all good sources. Contracting with a traveling specialist who is already present in the county is far easier than recruiting a new one; you're simply formalizing a relationship with someone who is already serving the community.
In rural counties, an exception request stands or falls on evidence about supply. Trying hard is not the test, but the record of your outreach is how you find out who is really available. Good practices for rural documentation include:
Rural adequacy is a challenge that never fully goes away, because no plan's contracting effort can create providers who aren't there. The goal is to know your supply better than the file does, and to be able to prove it.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.