Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildLaunching a new Medicare Advantage or Medicaid managed care plan requires building a compliant provider network from scratch, on a deadline. This guide covers the unique challenges of a first-year build and how to avoid mistakes that can cost a new plan its adequacy review.
Building a provider network for a new health plan is categorically different from maintaining or expanding an existing one. An existing plan's network recruiters can point to a track record of prompt payment, established relationships with provider offices, and a familiar brand in the market. A new plan has none of that. You are asking providers to take a risk on an organization they don't know, with no claims payment history, no member panel to promise, and no peer referrals from colleagues already in the network.
That challenge is compounded by timeline pressure. For a new Medicare Advantage plan, CMS requires that a complete network filing be submitted as part of the application package: months before a single member enrolls. The network must be demonstrated adequate on paper before the plan has any economic relationship with the providers it's contracting. Getting providers to execute contracts before they have any reason to believe the plan will deliver volume requires both strong relationship skills and a compelling value proposition.
For Medicaid managed care plans, state procurement timelines vary, and a state may require a network adequacy demonstration as part of the award or readiness process. Take the dates from the state's procurement materials.
For a Medicare Advantage plan entering a new service area, CMS's application timeline is the primary driver of network build urgency. The CMS application cycle runs on a fixed annual calendar, and missing a deadline typically means a one-year delay to the next application cycle.
Since contract year 2024, under 42 CFR 422.116(a)(2)(ii), applicants must demonstrate compliance with the network adequacy standards as part of the application. For contract year 2027, CMS's application listed completed applications due February 11, 2026, and it notes that dates are subject to change. Letters of intent signed by both parties may stand in for contracts at the time of application and during the review, under 422.116(d)(7).
Work backward from that date in this order: service area finalization, recruiter hiring and fee schedule development, first provider outreach, signed contracts and LOIs, adequacy modeling, and the application itself. Credentialing should run alongside contracting. Use your own estimates for each step, and start well ahead, because hard specialties in rural counties do not close in a few weeks.
Plans that start recruiting too late, or face unexpectedly resistant markets, may find themselves filing with gaps. After filing, the application review runs through a deficiency notice and a Notice of Intent to Deny, which allows 10 days to respond.
One of the most consequential decisions in a new plan launch is service area selection: specifically, how many counties to include in the initial service area. The temptation is to propose a large service area to capture maximum enrollment potential. The risk is that building adequate networks across a large, diverse service area is extremely difficult for a first-year plan on a fixed deadline.
A tiered market entry approach reduces that risk: identify the counties where a compliant network can be built within the available time, launch in those counties, and expand in later benefit years as the network matures and the plan has a track record to support provider recruitment.
A sensible starting point is a small, contiguous group of counties where the plan has existing organizational presence, physician group relationships, or hospital partnerships. Building in a few counties with strong relationships is far easier than building in many counties from a standing start.
Service area decisions are difficult to reverse after application submission. A plan that can't demonstrate adequacy in some of its proposed counties at filing time faces a choice between relying on exception requests (high risk, since CMS denied 259 of 448 in 2021, about 58%, according to MedPAC's June 2024 report) or dropping those counties late in the process. Starting smaller and expanding deliberately avoids both outcomes.
Provider recruitment for a new plan involves a distinct set of objections that experienced network recruiters working for established plans rarely encounter. Understanding these objections in advance allows recruitment teams to prepare responses and reduce the sales cycle.
The most common first-year recruitment objections include: "I've never heard of your plan, who's going to enroll in it?" (volume uncertainty); "We had a bad experience with [similar plan]: how are you different?" (payer reputation concerns); "Your credentialing process is going to be a nightmare because you're new" (administrative concern); and "What's your prior authorization process going to look like?" (administrative burden concern).
Fee schedule negotiations also run harder for new plans. Without a payment track record, providers have no basis for believing the plan will pay promptly and accurately. Plans that can provide contractual prompt payment commitments, escrow arrangements during the first year, or audit rights over claims adjudication are better positioned to overcome this objection than plans that simply ask providers to trust them.
A new plan may also be building its credentialing operation from scratch, without established relationships with hospitals and IPAs. Build those relationships in parallel with provider recruitment.
Credibility is the currency of new plan network building. Every interaction with a provider organization in the first year either builds or erodes the plan's credibility as a counterparty. Network operations leaders who approach first-year recruitment with a credibility-building framework, rather than a pure contract-closing framework, tend to build better networks.
Letter of intent (LOI) messaging for a new plan should lead with the plan's organizational backing, leadership credentials, and the specific value proposition for the provider's patient population. A new plan that can point to experienced managed care leadership, a well-capitalized parent organization, and a specific commitment to serving an underserved population in the market has a credibility story to tell.
Plan leadership relationships are often the most effective credibility-building tool in a first-year build. If the plan's CMO or CEO has existing relationships with medical group leaders or hospital network executives in the service area, those relationships should be deployed in recruitment. A call from a known executive carries more weight than a cold outreach from a recruiter the provider has never met.
Leveraging existing organizational relationships, pharmacy partnerships, ancillary provider contracts, risk-bearing entity relationships, can also accelerate network building. A plan that enters a market with an existing relationship with a large pharmacy group or a dominant medical group has a foundation to build from that a completely new entrant does not.
First-year network builds can be a good use case for external network development consultants, who may bring existing provider relationships in the target market and experience with new plan entrants.
Get quotes and compare them with the cost of hiring, training, and managing an internal recruitment team, including the time that team needs to get up to speed. For a single service area or a limited footprint, consulting support may be the more economical option.
The case for building internal capacity is stronger for plans that expect to expand across multiple markets soon, since those skills can be reused without repeated consultant engagements.
Delegated credentialing, where the plan delegates credentialing authority to a hospital, IPA, or medical group that performs primary source verification on the plan's behalf, is an attractive option for first-year builds because it allows the plan to credit credentialing completed by an established organization rather than building credentialing infrastructure from scratch.
The pros of delegated credentialing for new plans are real: faster credentialing turnaround, reduced administrative burden, and the ability to count providers credentialed by a trusted delegated entity without maintaining a full credentialing operation. The cons are equally real: the plan remains fully responsible for the accuracy of delegated credentialing and must conduct oversight audits of the delegated entity; delegated credentialing relationships require their own contracting and setup time; and not all providers are credentialed through entities willing to accept delegation from a new, unknown plan.
For first-year builds, a hybrid approach often works best: use delegated credentialing for providers affiliated with large hospital systems or IPAs that have established credentialing programs, while building direct credentialing capacity for independent providers and small practices that aren't affiliated with a delegatable entity.
New plans face some built-in risks: providers may fall out of the network after filing because the relationship is new, the credentialing process is new, and the directory is being built from scratch. Applicants that used letters of intent also go through CMS's triennial review in their first operational year, and each LOI must become a fully executed contract.
Address each risk directly. To reduce provider fallout, file with enough depth that losing one provider doesn't drop you below the standard, and keep working every LOI toward a signed contract. To reduce credentialing errors, audit files before you rely on them. To reduce directory errors, call a sample of providers before filing to verify that the directory information is accurate.
A network that exists on paper is not the same as a network that is operationally ready to serve members. Launch day readiness requires that every contracted provider knows they are in-network, knows how to verify member eligibility, knows the plan's claims submission requirements, and is listed accurately in the member-facing provider directory.
Provider communication for a new plan launch should include: a welcome communication to all contracted providers with the plan's effective date, claims submission information, and key contact numbers; a provider portal or EDI enrollment for electronic claims submission; and a dedicated provider services phone line staffed and ready before the first member enrolls.
The provider directory, the member-facing tool that allows enrolled members to find in-network providers, is a CMS compliance obligation as well as a member experience requirement. First-year plans that launch with an inaccurate directory face both member complaints and CMS directory accuracy scrutiny. Directory accuracy starts with clean data at contracting and credentialing: the directory can only be as accurate as the underlying provider records that feed it.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.