Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildFee schedule strategy isn't just a finance question, it's a network adequacy question. A fee schedule that lets recruiters make decisions quickly, without escalation, keeps negotiations moving. Here's how to structure your approach.
One bottleneck in contract closure is internal: the time it takes for a recruiter to get a fee schedule approved, modified, or escalated when a provider counters.
Without a clear fee schedule authority framework, a recruiter who receives a counter-offer must go back to their manager, who may escalate to a VP, who may need sign-off from the medical director or CFO. Each round takes time, and in a service area with a hard adequacy deadline, you may not have it.
The solution isn't to authorize recruiters to pay anything. It's to build a tiered authority framework that eliminates unnecessary escalation while maintaining appropriate financial controls at higher payment levels.
A well-designed fee schedule authority framework distinguishes clearly between what a recruiter can decide, what requires a manager or VP, and what requires medical director or executive sign-off.
At the recruiter level, the framework should authorize payment up to a defined percentage of Medicare, which your finance team sets for each market, for standard specialty categories without escalation. A recruiter who can say "yes" without calling their manager can move much faster.
At the VP or network director level, the framework should authorize a higher defined level for categories where the plan has documented adequacy gaps. This tier should have a streamlined approval process, such as a quick email authorization rather than a committee meeting.
At the medical director or CFO level, the framework should govern anything above shortage specialty premium levels, carve-out arrangements, capitation rates, or risk-sharing contracts. These arrangements warrant careful review, but they should be the exception, not the bottleneck that slows every negotiation.
Document the authority framework clearly and make it accessible to every recruiter. Ambiguity about who can approve what is itself a delay source: recruiters who aren't sure whether they need approval will escalate unnecessarily.
Medicare fee schedule rates are the foundational benchmark for commercial and MA network contracting. They represent a government-published, nationally consistent rate for every procedure code, and they give recruiters a shared reference point that most providers also understand.
Where to start depends on the market. Where providers are accustomed to MA contracting, a Medicare-based offer may be familiar. Where commercial rates are the main frame of reference, you may need to start higher to be taken seriously.
For specialist categories, market benchmarking is essential. Local claims data, published compensation surveys, and what your network team hears in the market should inform specialty-specific benchmarks. Using Medicare as the only benchmark in a market where commercial rates run well above it will slow your build.
Some specialty categories are short in many markets. For these, waiting for providers to accept standard rates can leave a gap open, and an exception won't rescue you: CMS's guidance says inability to contract is not a valid reason. Premiums are one lever for recruiting in high-demand categories.
Your own outreach results and decline reasons will show which specialties need a premium in your market. Behavioral health is a common place to look.
The appropriate premium level varies by market and by the severity of your adequacy gap. The calculation changes when you price the risk of failing to close.
Build shortage specialty premium authority into your fee schedule framework from the start, not as an exception that requires special approval. If you know dermatology is a shortage specialty in your service area, pre-authorize the premium and eliminate the escalation delay.
When a recruiter loses a provider because the fee schedule wasn't competitive by a small margin, the direct cost of that premium is easy to calculate. The adequacy cost is less obvious, but it's real.
Say a plan needs one dermatologist to meet the standard in a county, and only one is willing to participate. If that negotiation fails over rate, the plan has a gap, and it probably has no exception either, because a provider who is available and declined your rate is a contracting decision under CMS's guidance. For an applicant, that can cost the county.
When your recruiters are close to adequacy threshold in a given county and specialty, the fee schedule decision is not purely a rate question: it is an adequacy question with a compliance cost attached. Train your network leadership to think about fee schedule decisions in those terms, not just as line-item budget decisions.
Single-year contracts create annual re-negotiation cycles that consume recruiter capacity, create relationship friction, and generate re-contracting risk. Every annual renewal is an opportunity for a provider to exit the network or extract a significant rate concession. Plans that rely heavily on one-year agreements are perpetually re-building their networks.
Multi-year contracts with automatic rate escalators, tied to the Medicare fee schedule update, CPI, or a fixed percentage, reduce re-negotiation burden. A multi-year contract with a clear escalator can appeal to a provider because it offers revenue certainty, and to the plan because it adds network stability and cuts re-contracting work.
When negotiating multi-year terms, ensure the escalator is defined clearly: whether it applies to base rates or to all codes, whether it is a floor or a cap, and what triggers renegotiation if the underlying Medicare rate structure changes materially. Contracts that define escalators vaguely generate disputes at renewal that offset the stability benefit.
Fee-for-service contracting is the standard for most provider relationships in MA networks, but fee-for-service isn't always the right structure. For certain provider types and market contexts, alternative payment arrangements can accelerate network building and align provider incentives with plan goals.
Capitation makes sense for primary care groups with strong managed care experience and sufficient patient volume to absorb actuarial risk. It simplifies administrative burden for both plan and provider and aligns incentives around total cost of care. It is generally not appropriate for low-volume specialty relationships where actuarial risk is difficult to price.
Shared savings arrangements, where the provider shares in savings against a benchmark, work well for high-volume specialist groups and integrated delivery systems that are capable of managing utilization. These arrangements require more negotiation and administrative infrastructure but can produce meaningful network stability and quality alignment.
For new plan entries in markets where providers are skeptical of your ability to deliver volume, risk corridors, provisions that guarantee the plan will hold a provider harmless if attributed membership falls below a defined threshold in year one, can be a powerful accelerant. They reduce provider reluctance to join a network with no established membership base.
In some negotiations, rate is not the primary obstacle. Providers who are already accepting multiple MA plans at similar rates often have other decision drivers that a focused recruiter can address more effectively than by moving the rate.
The most common non-rate drivers include: administrative simplicity (streamlined claims submission, predictable payment timelines, minimal prior authorization requirements); prompt payment performance (providers who have been burned by slow payers are highly responsive to commitments backed by contractual prompt payment terms); and prior authorization reduction (for plans willing to carve out certain procedure categories from PA requirements for high-quality providers, this is a meaningful differentiator).
Ask directly. A recruiter who asks a provider what matters most to them, beyond rate, will often learn that the real objection is a bad experience with a prior payer, not the fee schedule itself. Addressing the actual concern closes contracts that a rate negotiation never would.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.