The Shortage Is Not a Cycle. It's a Structure.
Network build leaders hear some version of the same reassurance: the specialty shortage will ease as more providers graduate, as reimbursement rates improve, as the market self-corrects. We wouldn't build a strategy around it.
The evidence is clearest in behavioral health. When HHS-OIG looked at 2021 data in selected counties, it found fewer than 5 active behavioral health providers per 1,000 enrollees in both Medicare and Medicaid. Nobody recruits their way out of that in one filing cycle. In nephrology and oncology, our judgment is the same: outside the big metros, there are few practices to approach, and many answer to a health system.
Plan on that early. Otherwise you'll spend every filing cycle scrambling to explain the same gaps.
Telehealth Is a Legitimate Adequacy Tool, Within Limits
CMS recognizes telehealth in network adequacy in a specific way, and it's worth designing in from the start rather than treating it as a fallback. In the 15 specialties listed in 42 CFR 422.116(d)(5), behavioral health being the clearest example, contracted telehealth providers earn a 10 percentage point credit toward the share of beneficiaries who must be within the time-distance standard. The credit lowers the bar; it does not by itself cure a deficiency.
This is not a workaround. A member in a rural county who has reliable video access to a licensed behavioral health provider is receiving meaningful access to care.
The limits are real: the credit applies where the network includes providers furnishing additional telehealth benefits in that specialty, and telehealth-only providers never count toward the minimum. But for behavioral health in particular, telehealth is one of the few tools that can legitimately close the last 10 points of a gap that the physical provider market cannot fill. See behavioral health network adequacy.
Academic Medical Centers as Network Infrastructure
It's worth rethinking academic medical centers, from "high-cost outlier" to "adequacy anchor." In markets where private-practice oncologists or nephrologists are unavailable, an AMC contract may be the only path to a compliant network.
This requires confronting the cost directly. AMC rates can be higher. But the alternative, a deficiency notice or a county you can't expand into, has its own cost. Consider treating AMC contracts in high-shortage specialties not as premium spend, but as infrastructure cost, similar to the cost of operating in a remote market.
The contracting posture matters. We'd come to an AMC with a multi-county, multi-year view rather than trying to squeeze rates on a single-year deal.
Exceptions Only Work for Real Supply Problems
Where the providers really aren't there, an exception may be the answer. But be precise about the test. Under 42 CFR 422.116(f), you have to show that the providers are not available and that your contracted network is available and accessible to most enrollees, consistent with the local pattern of care. CMS's guidance says inability to contract is not valid, so a provider who is practicing nearby and declines your rate doesn't qualify, however many times you called.
A strong request accounts for every provider inside the standard, with dated proof for each one marked not available, plus claims or a detailed explanation of where members in that county get care today. MedPAC reports CMS denied 58% of requests in 2021, most often because CMS found providers the plan had failed to include. We walk through it in how to request an exception.
The specialty shortage is not going to solve your network adequacy problem. Your telehealth contracts, your AMC relationships, and an honest census of who is really there are the tools you have.
Realistic planning means accepting that some counties will not gain the physical provider density you'd like. Accept this early, build your strategy around telehealth, AMC relationships, and evidence you can defend, and you'll spend less time in deficiency remediation than a plan still waiting for the market to change.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.
