Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildNot all specialties recruit at the same pace or price. A tiered contracting strategy lets you sequence outreach, allocate budget, and close the hardest providers before your filing window slams shut.
Every network build operates under a filing deadline set by CMS's schedule, and the HSD tables have to reflect signed contracts or, for applicants, mutually signed letters of intent, not a network that is in progress. So the sequence in which a plan contracts providers matters enormously. Start with the wrong specialties, spend your recruiter time on easy wins, and discover late that you have no oncologists signed, and you have a gap that better prioritization could have avoided.
A tiered specialty contracting strategy addresses this sequencing problem by explicitly classifying specialties into priority tiers based on their strategic importance, their contracting difficulty, and their impact on adequacy. The tiering framework tells your recruitment team where to spend effort first, how much compensation authority to deploy at each stage, and when to pivot from direct negotiation to alternative strategies for providers who won't sign.
Tiered contracting is also a budget discipline. Physician and specialist compensation rates vary dramatically across specialty categories, and the willingness of specific provider groups to contract at market rates, versus demanding above-market rates or value-add concessions, varies with their market power. A tiering framework that allocates compensation authority by tier allows network leadership to make deliberate decisions about where premium rates are strategically justified and where standard market rates should be held.
The most effective tiered contracting frameworks for Medicare Advantage network builds use a three-tier structure that groups specialties by their strategic function in the network.
Tier 1: Anchor specialists are the high-acuity, hard-to-contract specialty groups whose participation is non-negotiable for adequacy and whose absence creates the most member-access risk. These are typically the specialists members most urgently need when they face serious health events. Anchor specialists call for the most senior recruiter assignment, the longest outreach runway, and the highest compensation authority. Outreach to Tier 1 specialists should begin at the very start of the network build, because their contracting takes the longest.
Tier 2: Secondary fill providers are specialties that are important for adequacy and member access but where the contracting process is more standardized and the provider market is less concentrated. These specialties often have larger pools of available providers, more competitive compensation environments, and faster contracting timelines. Tier 2 outreach should begin in parallel with Tier 1 but with less senior recruiter assignment and standard compensation authority.
Tier 3: Thin-market specialties are categories where the provider market is thin in one or more of your service area counties, making full adequacy through contracting uncertain. Still contact every provider inside the standard. Some will sign, and for the rest you learn who is actually available, which is what an exception request under 42 CFR 422.116(f) turns on. Outreach alone won't earn an exception: CMS's guidance says inability to contract is not a valid reason.
The specific specialty assignment to tiers varies by market: a specialty that is abundant in a Large Metro county may be a Tier 1 challenge in a Rural one. So build your tiers from your own supply data and outreach results, not from a national list.
Tier 1 might include oncology or psychiatry, if providers in your market have significant leverage, or are employed by health systems that contract at the system level rather than provider by provider.
Tier 2 might include specialties with larger provider pools in your market and more independent physician groups open to direct contracting. They still matter, since CMS evaluates all 29 provider types and 14 facility types, but the contracting is more amenable to standard recruiter workflows.
Tier 3 is any specialty where your supply data shows very few providers within reach of a county. Your contracting team should start the provider census on day one rather than expecting to contract a provider who may not exist within reasonable proximity.
Compensation authority, the rate range within which a recruiter can offer rates without senior leadership approval, should be stratified by specialty tier to match the market realities of each specialty category. A compensation authority framework prevents both underbidding (losing Tier 1 anchors because the recruiter couldn't offer a competitive rate) and overbidding (paying above-market rates for Tier 2 fill providers where competitive rates are sufficient).
Tier 1 authority levels should reflect the upper range of your market benchmarks, set by your finance team, with room for other considerations like care management fee arrangements or practice support.
Tier 2 authority levels should reflect market-competitive rates without a premium. A Tier 2 negotiation that needs escalation should prompt a review of whether the provider's market leverage warrants Tier 1 treatment.
Tier 3 authority needs care. In a thin market, one available provider may decide whether a county passes, and a rate dispute won't support an exception. Weigh the rate against the cost of leaving the gap open or leaving the county.
Sequencing outreach intelligently is as important as the tier classification itself. The goal is to structure your outreach calendar so that the longest-lead items begin earliest, the highest-leverage conversations happen when your contracting team has the most information and preparation, and your outreach record is building in parallel with active negotiation.
The first phase of the network build should focus on Tier 1 identification and initial outreach. This phase begins with market intelligence gathering: identifying which providers in each Tier 1 specialty are currently contracted with competing MA plans, which are independent versus health system employed, and which have a track record of participating in MA contracting. This intelligence shapes your outreach sequencing: independent providers are typically faster to contract than employed physicians whose agreements require system-level approval, so starting with the former gives you early credentialing starts while the longer health system conversations proceed in parallel.
The second phase should see Tier 2 outreach beginning at scale, Tier 1 negotiations advancing to rate discussion, and Tier 3 outreach starting to show who is really available.
The third phase is the highest-intensity negotiation period. Tier 2 contracting should be moving to execution, and you should have a clear picture of each Tier 3 market. Network leadership should be checking progress weekly against a specialty-by-county adequacy view to spot emerging gaps. Set the length of each phase from your filing date and your own past results.
Tier 1 specialists, particularly in high-demand specialties like oncology, psychiatry, and interventional cardiology, often have significant market power relative to any individual plan. Their practices or health system employers may already be contracted with multiple competing MA plans and can afford to be selective. Effective negotiation with Tier 1 anchors requires understanding what they value beyond the contracted rate and structuring the conversation around those value points.
Administrative simplicity can matter a great deal to specialist practices. Streamlined prior authorization for the procedure codes most relevant to a given specialty may be worth more to them than a slightly higher rate with burdensome requirements.
Prompt payment terms can matter too. Specialist practices with high procedural volumes have working capital needs, so faster clean claims payment can be a real concession when the rate discussion has stalled.
For health system-employed specialists, the conversation often needs to be had at the system level rather than the individual provider level. Building a relationship with the health system's managed care contracting team and framing the plan's participation as part of a broader system-level partnership, potentially including facility contracting, quality incentive arrangements, or joint care management programs, changes the dynamic from a transactional rate negotiation to a strategic partnership discussion. These conversations take longer but often result in system-level agreements that bring multiple Tier 1 specialists on board simultaneously.
Despite best efforts, Tier 1 outreach does not always succeed. A health system may be under an exclusivity arrangement with a competing plan. A specialist group may decline a plan with no enrollment in a new market. Individual providers may simply say no regardless of rate. Set a checkpoint in your schedule, early enough to act, and when it shows a county-specialty combination with no signed agreement, decide what happens next.
Alternatives include reaching out to providers in adjacent counties who may fall within the time and distance limits for the gap county's beneficiaries, since CMS's criteria are not restricted by county or state boundaries, and checking whether a telehealth credit applies in that specialty.
If the gap persists, look hard at why. A provider who contracts exclusively with another organization is a rationale CMS's guidance accepts. A provider who simply turned down your rate is not, because inability to contract is not a valid reason. Where the rule fits, prepare the exception request with a complete provider census and pattern-of-care evidence. Where it doesn't, your choices are to improve the offer, recruit someone else, or drop the county. Make that call while you still have time.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.