Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildLaunching a new Medicare Advantage plan is the most network-intensive build scenario a health plan team can face. You're building from zero, with no existing relationships, against established competitors who've been contracting in your target counties for years.
Network expansion, adding counties to an existing MA plan's service area, is difficult. First-year market entry is categorically different. In an expansion, you have existing provider relationships, an established brand in neighboring counties, a track record you can reference in contracting conversations, and a credentialing infrastructure already operating. In a first-year launch, you have none of those things. You are asking providers to contract with an organization that has no MA members, no claims history, no provider satisfaction track record, and, often, no meaningful recognition in the local market.
The psychological dynamic in first-year contracting is fundamentally different from expansion contracting. Providers and health systems evaluate new plans as credit risks, not just as network partners. They want to know whether the plan will be financially solvent long enough to pay claims. They want to know whether the plan's operational infrastructure, credentialing, claims processing, utilization management, care coordination, is mature enough to support a functional provider relationship. They want to know whether the plan's leadership has launched plans before and understands what it takes to operate in the MA space. These are legitimate concerns, and the network team's contracting pitch needs to address them directly.
First-year plans also face a chicken-and-egg problem that expansion plans do not. Providers are reluctant to contract with a plan that has no members; members are reluctant to enroll in a plan without a strong network; and CMS requires an adequate network to approve the plan for enrollment. The network build must achieve regulatory-grade adequacy before the plan can enroll its first member, which means building without the benefit of enrollment momentum or claims revenue to fund the contracting and credentialing operation.
The most consequential decision in a first-year MA launch is service area selection, which counties to include in the initial filing. Service area selection determines where you need to build a network, how many providers you need to contract, and how competitive the adequacy challenge will be. A plan that starts too large, trying to cover a multi-county or multi-state service area in year one, typically cannot build sufficient network depth in all counties simultaneously, resulting in adequacy failures and an operationally overwhelmed contracting team.
A first-year launch is usually better off with a concentrated service area in a single market. The target counties should be selected based on a combination of market attractiveness (Medicare population size, market growth rate, competitor quality gaps), network buildability (availability of contracted providers who are not exclusively tied to competitors, presence of independent physician practices that are reachable without health system agreements), and operational logistics (proximity to the plan's headquarters or operations center, familiarity with the regulatory environment).
County selection should also account for the adequacy challenge in each county, starting with its CMS designation (Large Metro, Metro, Micro, Rural, or CEAC) and its row in the HSD Reference File. Dense counties have more providers to choose from and tighter time and distance limits, and they are more competitive: established plans have long relationships with the best provider groups. Sparse counties have looser limits and may have less competition, but far fewer providers to choose from. Score each candidate before you commit, because the balance differs county by county.
Plans should also consider which counties allow them to anchor on a health system relationship. If the plan can secure a contract with the dominant health system in its target service area before building the rest of the network, that anchor relationship provides instant credibility with downstream specialty practices and improves the adequacy picture in hospital-based specialties significantly. Starting in counties where no health system partnership is achievable is a harder build that requires more time and more individual specialty contracts to reach adequacy.
In any market, a small number of provider organizations account for a disproportionate share of the MA patient volume and the perception of network quality among members. These anchor providers, typically the dominant health system, the largest primary care group, and the leading specialty practices in key specialties, should be the first targets of the network build, not the last. A new plan that secures contracts with the anchor providers before announcing its market entry is in a fundamentally stronger contracting position for all subsequent outreach.
Anchor providers also have strategic value beyond adequacy. When a first-year plan can tell a smaller specialty practice "we are already contracted with [dominant health system] and [largest PCP group]," it dramatically reduces the risk perception of the contracting relationship. Providers who might otherwise be reluctant to contract with an unknown plan are willing to engage when they see that the plan has already secured the anchor relationships that signal market commitment and operational credibility.
The approach to anchor contracting in a first-year launch typically involves direct engagement at the executive level before formal contracting begins. A meeting between the plan's CEO or President and the health system's Chief Strategy Officer or VP of Managed Care, focused on the plan's market rationale and the value it brings to the health system's covered lives, can open doors that a standard contracting letter cannot. Health systems are sophisticated evaluators of new plan partners: they want to know that the plan's leadership understands the market, is committed to operating here long-term, and has the financial backing to sustain a multi-year market presence.
Once anchor relationships are in place, the outreach sequence for specialty contracting should be driven by adequacy priority: the specialties that are most difficult to achieve adequacy in should be pursued earliest, because they have the longest contracting and credentialing timelines and the least margin for error. Which specialties those are depends on your market, so let your county scores tell you. Behavioral health and thin surgical specialties are common places to look first.
Without brand recognition, the first-year plan's contracting pitch to specialty practices needs to lead with tangible value rather than relationship history. The most effective value propositions for first-year specialty contracting include: competitive fee schedules that are meaningfully above the dominant plan in the market (if the plan's financial model supports it), simplified prior authorization processes that reduce administrative burden for specialty practices, a dedicated provider relations contact who will be directly reachable for issue resolution (a significant differentiator from large established plans where specialty practices often struggle to reach anyone), and the opportunity to be listed as a preferred or featured specialist in the plan's directory: a meaningful marketing benefit for specialty practices trying to build their MA patient volumes.
Sequencing should also account for credentialing. In most plans, a provider isn't loaded as participating until the credentialing committee approves the file, and several state laws give insurers 60 days from a completed application, with the time before an application is complete on nobody's clock but yours. For an application, a signed contract or a letter of intent signed by both parties has to be in place by the upload, and the plan needs signed contracts by the start of the contract year. Leave plenty of time for negotiation and credentialing behind those dates.
Provider reimbursement rates are the most powerful lever in first-year contracting, and new plans face a genuine dilemma: they need competitive rates to attract providers, but they have no claims experience to calibrate what rates they can sustain at the utilization patterns that will emerge from their initial membership. The financial risk of overpricing the network in year one, committing to rates that the plan's premium revenue cannot support at realized utilization, is significant.
One practical approach is to use percent of Medicare as the unit of negotiation rather than absolute dollar amounts. It gives providers a benchmark they understand and can compare against other plans' contracts. What's competitive differs by market and specialty, so set the numbers with your actuaries and what your contracting team is hearing locally.
Rate positioning should be differentiated by specialty and by the strategic importance of the provider. Anchor providers, the health system, the dominant PCP group, may warrant a premium rate to secure the relationship. High-volume commodity specialties where multiple contracted providers are available can be contracted at or slightly above market rates without affecting adequacy. Hard-to-recruit specialties in thin counties may require a meaningful rate premium to attract any contracted provider. The financial model needs to account for this rate differentiation rather than using a single blended rate assumption.
A formal health system partnership, whether a preferred provider agreement, an aligned incentive arrangement, or a value-based contract structure, provides a first-year plan with something that money cannot easily buy: institutional credibility in the local market. A health system that publicly endorses a new plan, even informally, through staff communications or provider communications, signals to the market that the plan has met the health system's vetting standards. This signal is particularly powerful in markets where a single dominant health system has a strong community presence.
Health system partnerships for first-year plans typically begin with a standard network contract and evolve toward deeper alignment as the plan's enrollment grows and claims data accumulates. In year one, the most realistic partnership structure is a preferred network designation: the health system is designated as the plan's preferred hospital system, it is listed prominently in the plan's directory and marketing materials, and the plan commits to a minimum quality and service standard in its relationship with health system providers. More sophisticated value-based arrangements are typically deferred to year two or three when the plan has the data infrastructure and member volume to support them.
Plans should be cautious about over-promising in health system partnership discussions. Expect a health system to be skeptical of a new plan promising a value-based relationship it has no data to support yet. A realistic, modular partnership proposal, start with a standard contract, build the relationship through year one performance, expand into aligned incentives when the data supports it, is more credible and more likely to succeed than an ambitious partnership structure the plan cannot execute on day one.
The staffing model for a first-year MA network build is fundamentally different from the staffing model for an expansion. An expansion leverages existing credentialing infrastructure, existing provider relations relationships, and existing contracting templates. A first-year build needs to build all of those things simultaneously while also building the network itself. Understaffing the build team is one of the most common and most costly mistakes in first-year MA launches.
A first-year build team should include: a network development director with MA contracting experience, enough network contracting specialists for the counties in the initial service area, a credentialing manager with experience running an accredited program, and a credentialing coordinator to move provider applications through the process. In addition, the team needs access to legal counsel for contract review, financial actuarial support for rate modeling, and CMS regulatory expertise for the adequacy submission and approval process.
Outsourcing to a credentials verification organization (CVO) or other delegate is an option that can speed up a first-year build by avoiding the need to stand up a full in-house credentialing program from scratch. The outside program does the work, with the plan providing oversight in accordance with delegation requirements. This approach can suit plans that do not expect to have sufficient long-term provider volume to justify a fully independent credentialing program. The tradeoff is loss of direct operational control and a per-provider credentialing fee that the plan must account for in its operating cost model.
The network test comes earlier than many first-time applicants expect. Under 42 CFR 422.116(a)(2)(ii), beginning with contract year 2024, applicants must demonstrate compliance with the network adequacy standards as part of the application, and CMS may deny an application based on its network evaluation. For contract year 2027, the Notice of Intent to Apply was due January 23, 2026, completed applications were due February 11, 2026, and bids were due June 1, 2026. CMS notes that its dates are subject to change, so check the current application.
Work backward from the application date, in this order: market analysis and service area selection, scoring candidate counties against the current HSD Reference File, anchor provider contracting, standing up credentialing, specialty contracting, and filling gaps. After filing come a deficiency response and then a response to any Notice of Intent to Deny, which is due within 10 days under 42 CFR 422.502(c)(2)(ii). Our rule of thumb, which is practitioner judgment and not a CMS requirement, is to have the county list and target providers by June of the year before the February application.
Delays in anchor provider contracting are common, because health system negotiations are complex and often involve issues beyond the network team's control, and they squeeze everything downstream. A plan with a significant anchor delay should revisit its service area rather than try to build without the anchor. Being realistic about what fits in the time left is what keeps a first-year application from failing county by county.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.