Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildNetwork adequacy and Star Ratings are often run as separate workstreams. But adequacy decisions, which providers are in network and how accessible they are, shape the member experience and clinical measures your Star Rating draws on.
CMS's Star Ratings for Medicare Advantage draw on member survey results from CAHPS, clinical measures from HEDIS, and complaint data, among other sources. Network decisions can touch all three. Check CMS's current technical notes for the exact measures and weights in any given year.
The connection is easy to follow. When members cannot reach a needed specialist in a reasonable time, they can report worse experiences on CAHPS. When a primary care physician cannot get a timely specialist referral, care gaps can linger and HEDIS results can suffer. When members have trouble getting appointments, they may complain to the plan or to CMS.
Running adequacy and Stars as separate workstreams, with different teams and reporting cycles, makes this connection hard to see. The network team is focused on county and specialty results; the quality team is focused on CAHPS scores and HEDIS rates. Neither sees how the other's decisions affect its own numbers.
The CAHPS survey asks Medicare Advantage members how often it was easy to get the care they needed and how often they got appointments as soon as they needed them, for both routine care and specialists. Those questions are where a network's access problems show up in member responses.
The pathway is direct. A member who needs a cardiologist and is told that the plan's contracted cardiologists have long new patient waits may, if surveyed, report that it was not easy to get needed care. If that member keeps having trouble getting an appointment, they may also file a complaint or grievance.
Plans often react to poor CAHPS scores by investing in member experience programs: care coordinator outreach, call center improvements, member advisory panels. These investments are valuable, but they cannot overcome a network composition problem. A member who genuinely cannot see a cardiologist within a reasonable timeframe will not report a better experience because they received a friendly call from a care coordinator. The underlying access barrier must be resolved through network contracting before member experience initiatives will have their full impact on CAHPS scores.
Timing matters too. Star Ratings are published well after the member experience they reflect, so a network improvement made this year won't show up in the ratings right away. Plan for that lag when you decide how early to make these improvements.
HEDIS clinical measure performance depends in part on which providers are in network and how actively they pursue preventive care and chronic disease management. Plans do not control clinical practice; they control which practitioners their members can see.
High-performing HEDIS measures require providers who order preventive screenings, close care gaps proactively, document diagnoses accurately (which also affects risk adjustment), and refer patients appropriately for follow-up services. Providers who are reactive rather than proactive in their clinical approach, who only address issues when a patient presents with a complaint, rather than proactively pursuing annual wellness visits, cancer screenings, and chronic disease monitoring, contribute to HEDIS gaps that accumulate into lower Star Ratings.
Plans that contract primarily on adequacy criteria, geographic coverage and specialty mix, without integrating provider quality data into the contracting process are building networks that may pass CMS thresholds but fail to support the clinical measure performance needed for high Stars. Care management programs can only do so much if the underlying provider network is not oriented toward preventive care and gap closure.
Care gap closure, the process of identifying members who have missed preventive services, overdue screenings, or lapsed chronic disease monitoring, and ensuring those gaps are addressed, is the operational mechanism through which HEDIS clinical measures improve. Care gap closure depends on provider cooperation: the member's primary care physician must be willing to act on care gap alerts, schedule the relevant service, and document the encounter in a way that creates a claimable event for HEDIS measurement.
When a plan's network has access barriers, members assigned to primary care physicians who are not accepting new patients, or PCPs with large panel sizes that limit appointment availability, care gap outreach frequently fails at the appointment scheduling step. The care management team identifies a gap, sends an alert to the provider or the member, and the member cannot get an appointment within the measurement year's window. The gap remains open and the HEDIS measure does not improve regardless of how effectively the care management team performed its outreach function.
Increasing the availability of primary care appointments, either by recruiting additional PCPs in high-gap areas or by making sure contracted PCPs keep panels open, removes a barrier to those appointments. Plans can test this in their own data by comparing care gap closure rates and adequacy results county by county.
Network strategy doesn't have to stop at adequacy compliance. In a quality-aligned contracting model, provider selection considers clinical performance alongside geographic coverage. This approach, sometimes described as value-based network design, uses HEDIS performance data, patient experience data, and quality measure participation records to inform which providers to actively recruit and which providers to credential but not actively promote.
Quality-aligned provider selection requires data that many network teams don't have in their contracting workflows. HEDIS measure performance at the individual provider level, patient experience survey results where available, preventive care ordering rates, documentation quality for risk adjustment purposes, and participation in quality improvement programs are all relevant inputs. Assembling this data takes close work between the network team and the quality analytics team.
A practical starting point is to compare available quality data, such as public CMS provider data, prior-year HEDIS performance where available at the provider level, and patient experience scores, against the provider contracting pipeline. Providers with strong quality profiles in high-priority HEDIS measure categories should be prioritized in contracting outreach. Providers with documented quality concerns should be contracted for adequacy purposes but not actively promoted through network positioning or value-based incentive programs.
Blueprint doesn't hold quality or HEDIS data. It tracks the contracting pipeline and adequacy scoring by county and specialty, and its CSV export lets a quality team compare that work against their own measures.
It's worth asking more than "does this network pass adequacy?" A better question is "does this network support the member outcomes and experiences that produce Stars?" These are related but distinct questions, and the second takes more data and more work across teams.
A network that passes CMS adequacy is the minimum bar. A network that supports Stars needs enough provider depth that members get timely appointments, providers who pursue preventive care and close care gaps, sufficient behavioral health access, and a geographic spread that reduces barriers for members with the greatest needs.
Closing that distance takes sustained work: setting quality-aligned contracting criteria, sharing reporting between network and quality teams, using care gap data to find where network improvements could help most, and aligning provider incentive programs with the clinical behaviors behind HEDIS results.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.