Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildOutreach logs matter, but good-faith effort is not what wins a CMS exception. When a rural county lacks enough providers, here's what CMS actually asks for and how your documentation supports it.
Many teams talk about a "good-faith effort waiver." The regulation doesn't offer one. What it offers is an exception request under 42 CFR 422.116(f), and CMS is not asking whether you tried hard. It is asking whether the providers you would need are actually available, and whether your members will get care the way people in that county already do.
You must show two things. First, the providers you would need to meet the standard are not available in that county and specialty. Second, the providers you did contract with are currently available and accessible to most enrollees, consistent with the local pattern of care.
CMS's December 2024 network adequacy guidance says "inability to contract" is not a valid reason. Neither are the plan's own internal standards. So a provider who simply declined your offer doesn't support an exception, unless that provider contracts with no MA organization or contracts exclusively with another one. A strong outreach record is useful, but it can't make up for providers who are still there and still billing Medicare.
A complete list of the providers of that specialty inside the standard, starting from CMS's Provider Supply file. CMS warns that the file may not be a complete depiction of supply, so check NPPES too. Remember the criteria are not restricted by county or state boundaries. For each provider, document NPI, practice address, specialty, and current network status.
A chronological record of outreach to each provider on the census. For each attempt, document date, method (phone, mail, email, in-person), person contacted, and outcome. The value of the log is what it teaches you: who retired, who moved, who opted out of Medicare, and who contracts exclusively with another organization.
CMS's guidance lists valid rationales, including a provider who is no longer practicing, not practicing at the address or in the specialty the supply file shows, opted out of Medicare, or on the OIG exclusion list. Attach something a reviewer can check, such as a license lookup, an opt-out check, or a dated outreach note.
Your internal claims data, or a detailed explanation, comparing the closer non-contracted providers with the farther contracted ones. It should let a reviewer conclude that contracting with the closer provider would not change where people actually get care.
Your records should be made as the work happens, because they are hard to reconstruct after the fact. Start logging outreach in shortage counties as soon as outreach begins. MedPAC's June 2024 report says the most common denial reason in 2021 was providers the plan failed to include, and a census takes time to build.
Blueprint records each outreach attempt and decline reason on the provider, and shows which counties and specialties fall short of the CMS standards. It can also produce a printable draft of an exception request for your team to review and complete.
Approval is not automatic: in 2021, CMS denied 259 of 448 exception requests, about 58%, according to MedPAC's June 2024 report. An approval isn't permanent either. Plans must resubmit previously approved exceptions whenever CMS requests an HSD upload, so re-verify each one as if it were new.
Keep working the underlying gap while an exception is in place, through telehealth credits where they apply, contracted providers in neighboring counties, and other routes to real access.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.