You Are Not Buying a Plan: You Are Buying a Network
When a Medicare Advantage plan acquires another MA plan, the transaction documents describe premium revenue, membership counts, Star Ratings, and market share. What they rarely describe with comparable rigor is the thing that makes all of those numbers possible or impossible to sustain: the provider network the acquiring entity is inheriting.
Networks are not assets in the traditional sense. They are webs of bilateral agreements: each one terminable, each one dependent on credentialing currency, each one attached to a specific provider who may be retiring, relocating, or already under-satisfied with contract terms. Acquiring a plan without understanding its network in granular detail is acquiring a liability dressed as an asset. The deficiency notice that arrives eight months post-close reflects decisions made before the deal: decisions the acquiring entity can no longer influence, only manage.
We'd treat network adequacy due diligence as a standalone workstream, run in parallel with financial and legal diligence, staffed by people who understand HPMS, HSD tables, and CMS compliance, not by generalist M&A analysts. The findings from that workstream should be material inputs to the deal structure, the purchase price, and the post-close integration plan.
The Four Dimensions of Network Due Diligence
A thorough network adequacy review of an acquisition target spans four areas, each of which can surface findings that affect deal economics.
Contract inventory and term analysis: Obtain the full contract roster: every provider agreement, every facility contract, every delegated credentialing arrangement. For each contract, the diligence team needs the term and expiration date, the termination notice requirements, any auto-renewal provisions, and the rate structure. Contracts that expire within 12 months of close require immediate attention: will they renew on existing terms, and does the target have existing relationships strong enough to support renegotiation at reasonable rates? Contracts with 30-day termination clauses are particularly important: they are nominally durable but practically fragile. A provider who is unhappy with the new ownership can exit before the acquiring plan has time to respond.
County gap analysis against current HSD requirements: Run the target plan's provider roster against current CMS HSD requirements for every county in the service area. This analysis requires the full provider file: contracted providers, their specialty designations, their practice locations, and their credentialing status. Map each provider against the applicable time-distance standard for their county's CMS designation. The output is a gap map: which counties are compliant, which are marginal, and which are already deficient under current standards. A strong overall percentage means little if the misses are concentrated in the highest-enrollment counties in the service area. Treat your result as an estimate: you are working without CMS's sample census, so ask for the target's own Network Management Module results.
Pending deficiency notices and CMS correspondence review: Request all CMS correspondence for at least the prior two review cycles, including deficiency notices, compliance actions, and any exception requests that were submitted. Have counsel confirm how open items transfer in your deal structure, since they may not disappear at close. Repeated deficiency notices point to a structural adequacy problem, not a one-time gap. Also ask when the next triennial review falls, and whether anything could trigger one early: a significant termination, a complaint, or a disclosed gap.
Credentialing status and currency audit: Request the credentialing files for a meaningful sample of the target's provider roster, weighted toward the counties with the thinnest coverage. Review for expired credentials and missed recredentialing. NCQA requires recredentialing at least every 36 months, so if the target is accredited that is a clear yardstick. A provider with lapsed credentials on an adequacy table is a problem you would rather find before close.
What Exception Files Reveal
The target plan's prior exception requests are one of the most revealing artifacts available in network due diligence, and they are easy to overlook.
A good file, under 42 CFR 422.116(f), accounts for every provider inside the standard, with dated proof for those not available, and shows that the contracted network fits the local pattern of care. That tells you the team knows its markets. A file that explains why the plan couldn't reach a rate with a provider tells you something else, because CMS's guidance says inability to contract is not a valid reason. Ask how many requests were denied and why. MedPAC reports CMS denied 58% of requests in 2021.
The quality of a plan's exception requests says a lot about its adequacy operations. The acquiring entity inherits whatever they reveal.
Review several years of exception files if you can get them. Are the same counties recurring? Plans must resubmit approved exceptions whenever CMS requests an HSD upload, so an approved exception is a finding at a point in time, not a permanent waiver. Recurring counties are chronic adequacy problems, and you should price them that way.
Structuring the Deal to Reflect What You Found
Network due diligence findings should feed directly into deal structure. A target plan with open deficiencies, credentialing gaps, and weak exception files is not the same asset as a target plan with a clean history. The purchase price, the representations and warranties, and the post-close integration budget should reflect that difference.
Specific provisions to consider: an escrow or holdback tied to the outcome of the next CMS network review post-close, seller representations on the completeness of the provider roster and credentialing status, and indemnification for deficiency notices arising from network gaps that existed pre-close. Take them to your deal counsel.
Post-close, budget for the integration work that network due diligence reveals. A plan with credentialing gaps needs recredentialing capacity. A plan with chronic deficiency counties needs outreach investment in those counties before the next upload. A plan with weak records needs process and tooling investment. These costs can be estimated at due diligence, so build them into the integration budget before close, rather than running an emergency program against a CMS date.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.