Why Network Adequacy Budgets Go Wrong
A typical adequacy budget is built from the top down: someone estimates a total based on what was spent last year, adjusts it for inflation and any known expansions, and submits it for approval. That produces a budget that reflects last year's spending patterns, not the actual cost structure of the work. Outreach staffing and credentialing capacity end up underfunded, and the money gets spent anyway in the final months, when the team is scrambling to close gaps.
The alternative is a bottom-up budget built from the actual cost drivers. Here is that model, line by line. We don't print salary or vendor figures, because we haven't found a public benchmark we would stand behind. Fill it in from your own HR bands, your own throughput history, and real quotes.
The Four Cost Buckets
Staffing: outreach, credentialing, and analytics: This is usually the largest cost driver. There are three distinct functions.
- Provider outreach: Start from your gap list. How many providers need contacting, how many touches does each one take across the sequence, and how many contacts can one person work in a week? Those three numbers size the team.
- Credentialing: Credentialing throughput is the constraint teams find too late. Measure your own files per specialist per month, and remember that incomplete applications take longer. If projected signed contracts per month exceed that throughput, you're building a backlog.
- Network analytics: Someone must own the ongoing HSD analysis: scoring your current roster against the standards, identifying emerging gaps before they become deficiency findings, and maintaining the county-level view that leadership uses to prioritize outreach.
Technology: Budget for three categories. Time and distance modeling, whether a dedicated platform or an internal GIS solution, and ask how it measures distance. Provider data management, to keep a current roster tied to NPPES. And outreach tracking, a CRM or dedicated platform that holds the contact history for every provider. Get real quotes for each.
Consultant fees: If you use external consultants, common engagements include county selection and HSD modeling, exception request preparation, and upload support. Scope them against the specific gaps you have, not as a retainer.
CMS filing work: HPMS submission itself is not a line item, but the work around it is. Data validation, NPI checks, specialty code review, and calling providers to confirm they are accepting new MA patients all take analyst time. Build these into the budget as staff time at the fully loaded rate, not as zero-cost overhead.
Building the Multi-Year Model
A single-year adequacy budget is the wrong planning horizon. The work is continuous: it does not reset to zero after each upload, and CMS publishes a new HSD Reference File every year.
A defensible model has three phases. Year one is the baseline build: full staffing, full technology investment, and the highest consultant spend as the plan establishes its county selection logic. Year two is maintenance and gap closure: staffing levels stabilize, technology costs are known, and consultant spend should drop as internal capability matures. Year three and beyond is continuous adequacy: a steady-state budget for maintaining the network, re-scoring against each year's file, and managing credentialing for provider attrition.
The question a CFO should ask is not "what did we spend last year?" It is "what does a compliant adequacy operation cost, and are we funding it?" Those are different questions.
When presenting this model to a board or finance committee, anchor it against the alternative: emergency remediation after a deficiency notice, or a denied county in an expansion. MedPAC's June 2024 report says new applications have been denied on network adequacy grounds. The cost of a properly funded operation is predictable. The cost of an underfunded one is not.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.